O’Malley’s Market Minute | May 2026

Safety, Supply, and a Shifting Freight Floor

The freight market continues to send mixed signals. Consumer demand remains soft, economic uncertainty lingers, and yet there are growing signs that structural changes on the supply side could begin to put upward pressure on rates in the months ahead.

In the latest edition of O’Malley’s Market Minute, Bison Transport’s Director of Analytics, Shaun O’Malley, breaks down the latest economic indicators, what they mean for freight demand, and why a major U.S. Supreme Court ruling around broker liability could reshape the transportation landscape.

Watch the latest Market Minute

Demand Still Under Pressure

On the demand side, the story hasn’t changed dramatically.

Consumer sentiment continues to weaken, inflation remains persistent, and higher Treasury yields are adding pressure on household spending. While value-focused retailers like Walmart may continue to post strong results as consumers prioritize affordability, that doesn’t necessarily translate into stronger freight demand.

As O’Malley explains, consumers appear increasingly cautious about discretionary spending, particularly on goods that move through traditional truckload networks. The result is a freight environment that remains challenged on the demand side.

The Bigger Story: Supply and Safety

The more significant development may be unfolding on the supply side.

A recent unanimous U.S. Supreme Court decision regarding broker liability is expected to have major implications across the freight industry. The ruling effectively increases accountability for brokers regarding the safety standards of the carriers they hire.

At the same time, heightened public attention around carrier safety, including recent media coverage of “chameleon carriers” operating in the U.S., is increasing scrutiny across the industry.

According to O’Malley, this creates a new operating reality where safety programs, carrier vetting, compliance monitoring, and risk management become even more critical.

These programs require investment in people, technology, and processes. Many large asset-based carriers and established brokerages already have these systems in place, but the ruling could accelerate a broader shift toward trusted transportation partners with proven safety track records.

What This Could Mean for Freight Rates

While the ruling does not guarantee a rapid spike in freight rates, it may establish a higher floor in the market.

As compliance costs rise and weaker or underprepared carriers exit the market, capacity could tighten further. Combined with ongoing supply disruptions and seasonal volatility, that environment may gradually push rates higher over the short to medium term.

O’Malley also points to recent spot market movement during Roadcheck Week as another reminder that pockets of disruption continue to create temporary rate pressure throughout the market.

The broader takeaway: freight demand may still be soft, but the costs and complexity of operating safely are increasing, which could begin reshaping pricing dynamics across the industry.

Looking Ahead

The freight market remains uncertain, but the conversation is clearly evolving. Beyond demand cycles, the industry is increasingly focused on safety, accountability, and operational resilience.

For shippers, that reinforces the importance of working with transportation partners that have established safety programs, strong carrier vetting processes, and the operational discipline to navigate a changing regulatory environment.

Stay tuned for the next edition of O’Malley’s Market Minute as we continue tracking the trends shaping freight markets across North America.