While demand conditions across the North American transportation market have remained relatively steady, supply continues to strain. Rising operating costs, carrier bankruptcies, and increased scrutiny of carrier safety are pressuring available trucking capacity and creating the conditions for a potentially significant shift in transportation rates.
In the latest episode of O’Malley’s Market Minute, Shaun takes a closer look at the trucking market and what shippers should watch as we move into 2027.
A trucking industry under mounting financial pressure
The economics of operating an asset-based trucking business remain challenging. Higher fuel prices, rising insurance premiums, and the ongoing cost of capital are squeezing already-thin margins.
Trucking bankruptcies have continued to climb throughout 2026, with several hundred reported so far this year. Even well-managed carriers face increasingly difficult profitability amid elevated operating costs and limited pricing power.
Operating ratios across the industry illustrate just how tight those margins have become. Larger asset-based carriers generally report operating ratios in the mid-to-high 90s, while other operators are in the low-to-mid 90s.
With so little room between operating costs and revenue, carriers have limited ability to absorb further cost increases. Maintaining profitability increasingly depends on disciplined cost management and, ultimately, higher freight rates.
Carriers are pushing for higher contract rates
As Q4 and Q1 bid cycles begin, carriers are starting to signal the rate increases they believe are necessary to sustain their businesses.
Some major asset-based carriers are calling for opening bid increases ranging from the high single digits into double digits. While these increases will inevitably contribute to transportation cost inflation for shippers, they also reflect the cumulative impact of operating cost increases over the past two to three years.
The question now is how much of that pricing pressure the market will absorb as contract rates are renegotiated.
For shippers, this is an important development as they head into the next round of transportation procurement. The pricing environment that has characterized the past few years may not be sustainable if carrier operating economics continue to deteriorate.
Safety and compliance are contributing to capacity contraction
Financial pressure isn’t the only factor affecting available trucking capacity.
The post-Montgomery regulatory environment is adding another layer of scrutiny to carrier operations. Carriers that cannot meet evolving safety expectations are increasingly at risk of exiting the market, further reducing available capacity.
At the same time, freight brokerages and asset-based transportation providers are becoming more selective about the carriers they work with. This increased focus on carrier selection reflects growing concerns about safety, compliance, and the liability risk of using underqualified operators.
As a result, capacity isn’t simply disappearing because of financial pressures. Safety and compliance requirements are also influencing which carriers remain viable options for moving freight.
This reinforces the importance of working with transportation partners that have the operational infrastructure, safety programs, and carrier oversight to deliver consistently.
Why 2027 and 2028 could look very different
Looking ahead, the industry will need to find a path back to sustainable profitability. That will likely require continued rate increases through 2027 and into 2028.
The biggest variable is demand.
If current supply conditions persist while freight demand begins to recover, the transportation market could change quickly. With fewer carriers competing for available freight, even a modest demand increase could put significant upward pressure on rates.
In other words, tightening capacity and recovering demand could create a perfect storm for transportation rate increases across North America.
Fuel costs, tariffs, and broader policy developments will also be important factors to watch as the market evolves over the coming months.
What shippers should be thinking about now
For transportation buyers, the current environment reminds us that the lowest available rate doesn’t always translate into the most sustainable transportation strategy.
As capacity tightens, shippers should be considering:
- Reassessing transportation budgets: Build potential rate increases into 2027 planning rather than assuming current pricing will hold.
- Evaluating carrier relationships: Prioritize financially stable, safety-conscious transportation providers with the resources to navigate changing market conditions.
- Looking beyond individual lane rates: Consider how different modes, networks, and transportation solutions can create greater flexibility and resilience.
- Thinking strategically about procurement: Avoid making decisions based solely on short-term pricing. Reliable capacity and consistent service become increasingly valuable when the market tightens.
The transportation market hasn’t seen a meaningful demand recovery yet, but supply is already under significant stress. If those conditions continue, shippers could face a much different pricing environment when demand eventually picks up.
The takeaway: Capacity is leaving the market, operating costs remain elevated, and carriers are pushing for higher rates. The question isn’t just whether transportation rates will increase, but how quickly the market could move as demand catches up with shrinking capacity.
Watch the latest O’Malley’s Market Minute
Get more perspective on the forces shaping the North American transportation market, from carrier capacity and freight rates to the broader economic factors influencing supply chains.
Stay up-to-date with everything Bison

Customer Advisory: Southern Alberta Storm Watch

Fewer Trucks, Higher Rates? The Forces Reshaping the Trucking Market

